Visible, Viable, Valued and Visionary: the imperative of social care in Scotland.

There is never a dull moment in the world of social care in Scotland. In the past week we have ongoing debate about the National Care Service culminating in the decision of the Scottish Government to pause the Bill Stage 2 process and to return to the matter in 2025. This decision has been met by some who think it means the end of the Bill and by others who wish it did, and yet others who are both confused and disappointed.

I mention all this because yesterday was the Scottish Care Care Home conference. This annual event brought together care home providers, managers and workers, together with other stakeholders and partners from across the country. It was also an opportunity to hear from some of our political leaders, including the Cabinet Secretary Neil Gray, about their position on a whole range of issues, not least the National Care Service.

However, for most of those there the number one issue was not the future shape of social care (however critical that is) but whether they would be around to see it. Yesterday Scottish Care published a summary of some of our latest consultation with our members about the implications of the Westminster Labour Government’s intention to increase the National Insurance threshold and rates. Our research indicated that of those who responded to a survey in the past week, nearly half (48%) of care home and homecare organisations noted the very real possibility of service closure as a result of this increase.

In our media statement I said that:

“These additional pressures on social care providers created by the UK Budget announcement are unworkable in the current climate and a solution, either through exemption or funding, must be found in order for the social care sector to be sustained. Scottish Care is incredibly alarmed at the figures presented in our survey, not least around service closures, with many providers indicating that this may very well be the straw that breaks the camel’s back. It is no exaggeration to say we will lose swathes of social care provision in Scotland unless urgent, practical and resource-based solutions are progressed for the sector. If not, the impact on individuals, communities and public services will be catastrophic.”

It was in the context of such a troubling background that together with my colleague, Scottish Care’s Deputy CEO, Karen Hedge we ended the conference by focussing on the Four V’s which lie at the heart of Scottish Care’s recent Strategy document. What follows is a summary of what we shared:

Visible

Social Care that works for Scotland ​

In order to move forward you need to know who you are …

Scottish Care is essentially a membership organisation – we represent the greatest diversity and range of providers of social care in Scotland indeed probably in Europe – from care home to homecare, housing support to respite support. From small single operators to large corporate organisations; from rural to remote and urban to town.

We are an organisation driven by social values. We aim to ensure that social care in Scotland is not only sustainable but also exemplary, reflecting the high standards and compassionate care that our communities deserve.

The problem is that a lot of people do not know what social care is – we have got to the stage of it being seen as the release valve for the NHS on the one hand (not least around delayed discharge and avoidable admission) or as a set of services which is about maintenance and keeping people safe – it is so much more.

It is about flourishing and thriving – about citizenship and contribution, it is about challenging the discrimination of age and the limitation of conditions such as dementia.

social care is rather:

‘The enabling of those who require support or care to achieve their full citizenship as independent and autonomous individuals. It involves the fostering of contribution, the achievement of potential, the nurturing of belonging to enable the individual person to flourish.’

It is time for social care and care homes to be seen for what they are  – contributors and not costs, enablers of life and not limiters of freedom, places of thriving lives and not ante-rooms of the end days.

As a society we need to shout loudly about the brilliance of compassion and the dedication of our care homes staff and managers in the delivery of a society which values all.

We are here to build the possibility of a society that truly values care, and walks the talk of the rhetoric of priority.

Viable

Scottish Care also published yesterday our report on Ethical Commissioning which states clearly that we need to radically reconceive the way in which we commission and contract care services into a model which embeds human rights at its heart. It centres its focus on rights, respect and redistribution. People deserve high quality social care and support focussed upon human rights

Social Care is experiencing an increase in demand at the same time as a decrease in resource and it remains a net contributor to the economy. It is time to think differently and sustainably.

We need to start thinking about the potential for social care to be an economic and societal driver rather than using the language and mindset of cost and drain.  We need to focus on human rights – work collaboratively across the health and social care system in the preventative space and beyond, to make sure that people can live with autonomy for longer.

This all requires that we approach each other with mutual regard and transparency, creating trust in a system built upon robust cost of care modelling and funding this by reducing duplication and bureaucracy, bridging the implementation gap through a redistribution of funds.

We also need to support our amazing social care workforce through the implementation of Fair Work principles and sectoral bargaining, but we need to do this in a planned way with appropriate procurement measures. The implication and implementation of the Employee Rights Bill and the UK Budget have to be recognised both at Scottish and UK level. Almost half of our members responded to a survey on the budget saying that they may not be viable with the changes to National Insurance contributions alone, if these are not carried through into funding.

What we have stated before of net-zero is true still of commissioning:

“Many of the concerns circle back to the long-standing issue of insufficient funding available in the sector and the undervaluing of social care. Changing mindsets to focus on sustainability in the commissioning and procurement processes would be beneficial to implementing long-term change”

We no longer have a National Care Home Contract which is fit for purpose ands indeed the financial gap between true cost and public funding is between £4-500. Such a contract limits and the moral step away from funding the true cost of care cannot be excused.

Valued

At some point, everyone in Scotland is likely to experience care and support either directly themselves or indirectly for their loved ones.

It’s time to celebrate social care, a sector that makes a difference every day for the people of Scotland, whether you access, work in or provide it.

Despite the shelved human rights bill, we put human rights at the front and centre of our work, we know that value lies in people, not process but we need to do more to address discrimination in our society. Discrimination in our legislation which excludes older people living in care homes from access to self-directed support,  discrimination which has become so pervasive against older people we do not even notice it is there.

And societal discrimination in the form of microaggressions which for instance maintain that it’s women’s work, worthy only of a living wage, rather than a professional wage for professionally qualified and regulated individuals. That it’s women’s work, thinking which a recent study as part of IMPACT showed that deters men from considering a role in social care because they are too worried what their family might say thus perpetuating the myth.

Everyone in this room knows the worth of social care and support through the significant contribution it makes to society and our economy. Through the difference that it makes to our lives and in the measurement of humanity.

It’s time we broke through those barriers and set things right. It’s time for a care revolution to bring us social care that works for Scotland.

Visionary

All of us recognise that the seeds of change are rooted in the present moment, that the future is not an alien country but one we must all be citizens of. We can never stand still, we must always be re-imagining our today in a new direction.

So that is why Scottish Care is continually committed to asking the hard questions – what will a care home need to look like? How do we make services and support truly person-led with the citizen in charge and our services and staff there to enable them to direct their living?

That’s why technology and digital solutions and the emerging role of Ai are not a fad or a distraction but central and critical for the delivery of quality and rights-based care and support.

That’s why we will use design approaches to work with a range of stakeholders so that the people in this room and those who use services and support in care homes are at the forefront of coming up with a vision of tomorrow.

Whether through our work on data or research and policy we will continue to listen to the best the world of aged care has to offer in all corners of our globe, bring insights into this place and help to re-shape plans and possibilities into realities and revolution.

An American actor once said:

“Tomorrow is the most important thing in life. Comes into us at midnight very clean. It’s perfect when it arrives and puts itself in our hands.”

We all of us have the potential to create a vision of the possible for social care in Scotland, we can work together from all political standpoints to put aside short term self-interest and partisan positioning and identify what we can agree on and re-shape that tomorrow.

Tomorrow is fresh and full of possibility, if we dare to allow all that stops us from working together to be set aside.

Donald Macaskill

Karen Hedge

Photo from Joshua Sortino from Unsplash

Last Updated on 16th November 2024 by donald.macaskill